August 14, 2025: Added new Prismatic and Transcendent pie recipes.
How do you make pie in Grow a Garden? Whether you have a varied garden or curate only the coolest crops, you’ll have a way to farm Grow a Garden cooking event rewards with these Roblox Grow a Garden pie recipes.
If you haven’t managed to stock up on crops high up the Grow a Garden seeds tier list, you’ll want to keep a close eye on the next Grow a Garden update for your next chance to do so. Not sure if the Gourmet eggs are even worth the trouble? Give the Grow a Garden pets tier list a read while you wait for your next meal.
How to make pie in Grow a Garden
| Rarity | Easy Pie Recipe 1 | Easy Pie Recipe 2 | Heavy Pie Recipe | With Craving |
| Legendary Pie | Pumpkin, Moon Melon | Pumpkin, Pineapple | Pumpkin, Giant Pinecone, Corn, Apple | Not discovered |
| Mythical Pie | Pumpkin, Beanstalk | Pumpkin, Ember Lily | Beanstalk, Coconut, Coconut, Coconut | Tomato, Corn, Elder Strawberry, Sugar Apple, Ember Lily |
| Divine Pie | Coconut, Beanstalk | Sugarglaze, Beanstalk | Bone Blossom, Crown Melon, Fossilight, Sugar Apple, Sugar Apple | Any Prismatic (3), Tomato, Corn |
Making pie in Grow a Garden is one of the more complex recipes. Because of how many ingredients are needed, getting a normal or rare pie seems impossible.
To make a pie in Grow a Garden, you’ll need apples, pumpkins, and corn. Pumpkins and Coconuts are a perfect base for a pie. Experiment by tossing flavor rich crops in as a filling and you might just make a pie.
If you’ve been around the garden for a while, you’ll have a much easier way to make pies in Grow a Garden-the Moon Melon. Stick one of these in the pot after a pumpkin and you’ll have a GaG pie recipe with only two ingredients.
With weight contributing to better rewards, take a peek at our Grow a Garden recipes list to understand which ingredients make a filling pie.
Is the Prismatic Pie recipe worth it?
Unless you happen to have bone blossoms, prismatic and transcendent pie recipe aren’t likely to be a worthwhile investment. Want to try anyway? Toss these crops into the can by the big pig:
- Recipe 1:
- Bone Blossom (3)
- Sugar Apple
- Sugarglaze
- Recipe 2:
- Recipe 3 (craving only)
- Bone Blossom
- Sugar Apple
- Sugarglaze
- Recipe 4 (craving only)
- Sugarglaze
- Ember Lily x2
- Beanstalk x2
Looking for a boost outside of a craving? Try these Transcendent Pie recipes:
- Recipe 1:
- Recipe 2:
- Bone Blossom x2
- Sugarglaze
- Sugar Apple
Satisfied Chris P.’s Grow a Garden pie cravings? Prep his next meal by learning how to make salad in Grow a Garden and how to make ice cream in Grow a Garden. That way you’ll have both healthy and unhealthy meals to suit the needs of the hungry piggy.
